WHY PEOPLE STAY
Trusted by NJ families & businesses for 25+ years.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Rated 5.0 across Google, Yelp & Facebook.
25+
5.0
100%
EN/ES
A-Rated
YEARS SERVING NJ
GOOGLE RATING
WOMAN-OWNED
BILINGUAL TEAM
TOP CARRIERS
Pinank S.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Auto & home
"I got quoted very reasonable rates by Sam. He walked me through the entire process and coverage in detail and made sure I had all my paperwork done. I'd highly recommend Nistor Agency to anyone."
via Google · ★ Verified
Anna H.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Taxes & home, client 23 years
"Walter has been doing my taxes for at least 23 years. He knows the tax laws inside out. He also has my house insurance policies. I am truly grateful for all these years he has done my taxes and voiced his opinion about my homeowners insurance."
via Google · ★ Verified
Jorge C.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Commercial + personal
"Great service, I have my commercial and personal policy here."
via Google · ★ Verified
Juan J.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Auto insurance
"Cut my rate almost in half with better coverage. Super helpful and informative. I did have to wait a bit since there were people already in the waiting room but worth the wait."
via Google · ★ Verified
Julia S.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Auto coverage review
"Sam was super helpful in explaining my coverage and pricing. I thought I had full coverage with my old company, but I didn't, and I was paying more. I highly recommend coming here."
via Google · ★ Verified
R.R.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Seguros y contaduría
"Personas muy profesionales trabajando para la gente, ayudando a resolver dudas e inconvenientes en cuanto a seguros en general y contadurías. Muy recomendado."
vía Google · ★ Verificado
REAL WORLD RESULTS
What working with us looks like.
Medical office
CHALLENGE
Malpractice, liability, workers' comp, and payroll for a growing practice, spread across different providers with no one watching the whole picture.
HOW WE HELPED
Reviewed every policy side by side, closed the gaps, and quoted the full program across our nine carriers.
RESULT
Saved about $2,400 a year — and we caught a liability gap their previous broker never flagged.
Family-owned shop
CHALLENGE
Three separate vendors for insurance, payroll, and taxes, none of them talking to each other.
HOW WE HELPED
Brought all three under one roof with a single point of contact who knows the whole business.
RESULT
One call instead of three vendors. They've stayed with us for 15 years — even when a cheaper quote came along.
Local contractor
CHALLENGE
Certificates of insurance for every job, workers' comp audits, and renewals piling up faster than the actual work.
HOW WE HELPED
Took over the paperwork — same-day certificates, audit prep handled, renewals shopped across nine carriers before they hit.
RESULT
Same-day certificates, three years of clean audits, and roughly $1,800 trimmed at renewal.